@nicolethoen I think that might be more of a bug with button, but there are some ways we could resolve it NotificationBadge side.

I could pass the icon as a child of the Button when there isn't a count, and to the icon prop when there is so that things are properly spaced. How that will work with children of NotificationBadge could be tricky though.

I wonder if we should cut the flexibility of NotificationBadge back in penta since if a more custom solution is needed consumers can just customize the stateful Button themselves 🤔