Home Original page

[Python-Dev] I am now lost

[Python-Dev] I am now lost - committed, pulled, merged, what is "collapse"?

skip at pobox.com skip at pobox.com
Mon Mar 21 12:14:30 CET 2011 
    Stephen> It would be possible for the svn-based workflow to require that
    Stephen> after testing in one's workspace, one does an svn update, and
    Stephen> if any changes are made to files in the workspace, the whole
    Stephen> build and test procedure must be repeated.  I don't see that
    Stephen> that has advantages over the hg workflow, though -- it should
    Stephen> cause an addition build-test cycle in exactly the same revision
    Stephen> sequences that the hg workflow does.

It, however requires every developer to become facile, if not expert, with
the ins and outs of the Python/Mercurial workflow.  This discourages casual
or intermittent contributions.  My main contribution to the Python codebase
over the past couple years has been to intercept trivial "bug reports" sent
to the webmaster address calling out typos in the documentation or the
website.  Handling such reports was trivial with Subversion.  Update, edit,
check in.  That is no longer the case with Mercurial.  (And for the website
will no longer be the case in the fairly near future if I understand
correctly.)

I believe it runs counter to the professed intention of the switch away from
a centralized version control system, to make it easier for more people to
contribute to Python.  It certainly seems harder for this old dog.

Skip
More information about the Python-Dev mailing list